In a world overflowing with specialty coffee options, finding your next favorite roaster or coffee can be as daunting as it is exciting. Whether you're a coffee aficionado or someone exploring finer brews for the first time, navigating this vast landscape of beans, origins, roasters, and flavor profiles can feel overwhelming. The hosts of the Coffee Roaster Warmup Sessions podcast, Mark Katrski and Sergi Katrvski, recently dove into this very topic, offering a treasure trove of insights on how to confidently discover new coffee roasters and coffees that align with your taste.
This article breaks down their discussion into actionable steps while adding critical context for coffee lovers who want to elevate their coffee-drinking experience. Whether your goal is to brew a stunning cup at home or to explore new roasters in your local coffee scene, this guide has you covered.
Why Exploring New Roasters is Worth It
Trying coffee from a variety of roasters not only broadens your palate but also allows you to support local businesses, discover different roasting styles, and experience the richness of coffee from across the globe. However, the search for "the one" can be tricky. Investing $20, $30, or more on a bag of coffee that doesn’t meet your expectations is a risk many of us hesitate to take. The goal then becomes minimizing that risk while enjoying the adventure of discovery.
Mark and Sergi’s discussion sheds light on how to vet new roasters and their offerings while ensuring a positive experience. Let’s dive into their tried-and-true strategies.
sbb-itb-1d31003
1. Start with Trusted Producers
One of the most reliable ways to venture into new coffee territory is by focusing on producers you already love. Coffee producers play a massive role in determining the quality and flavor of the final cup. If you’ve enjoyed coffees sourced from specific farms or producers in the past, look for roasters who carry their beans. For example, if a producer like Diego Bermudez or Juan Peña has delivered excellent coffees before, choosing a new roaster working with the same producer increases your chances of finding something you'll enjoy.
Why it works: Coffee farms often produce beans with distinctive flavor profiles, and roasters who source from reputable producers are typically aligned with a commitment to quality. This approach gets you halfway to a satisfying cup.
2. Pay Attention to Flavor Notes
Flavor notes on coffee bags are your roadmap to understanding what’s inside. While they won’t guarantee an exact match to your taste buds, they provide key insights into the coffee’s profile. Look for descriptors that match your preferences - whether you crave vibrant fruitiness, chocolatey depth, or nutty warmth.
- Specificity matters: Detailed flavor notes (e.g., "stone fruit, elderflower, lime") often indicate a focus on nuanced roasting and quality, whereas vague descriptors like "smooth" or "sweet" might mean less precision.
- Match your roast level: If you love light and juicy coffees, steer clear of bags with notes like "smoky" or "bold", which often indicate darker roasts.
That said, not every roaster with broad flavor descriptions should be discredited. Some well-regarded names, like Prodigal Coffee, occasionally use simple flavor descriptors while delivering excellent cups. Use flavor notes as a guide, not a rule.
3. Understand the Coffee’s Processing Method
Processing methods (e.g., washed, natural, honey-processed) significantly influence a coffee’s flavor, and roasters who provide detailed information about the process demonstrate transparency and attention to detail. A clear explanation of the method - beyond just stating "washed" - can help you predict whether the coffee aligns with your preferences.
For example:
- Washed coffees often have clean, crisp flavors.
- Natural-processed coffees tend to showcase fruit-forward, intense notes.
- Honey-processed beans can offer balanced sweetness with a creamy body.
Detailed descriptions show that the roaster cares about educating their audience and delivering an intentional product.
4. Leverage Multi-Roaster Cafes and Curated Subscriptions
Multi-roaster cafes and subscription services are excellent resources for coffee discovery. These platforms often act as curators, thoughtfully selecting roasters and coffees based on quality and uniqueness. If you trust the taste and expertise of a multi-roaster cafe, their shelves or menu can become your window to new, exciting brands.
Tips for leveraging multi-roaster opportunities:
- Ask staff for recommendations tailored to your preferences.
- Look up the roasters featured on cafe shelves to explore their broader menus.
- Use curated subscription services that specialize in matching coffees to your flavor profile.
"Let other people do the hard work of vetting roasters", Mark suggests. Subscriptions can save you time and introduce you to high-quality options you might not discover otherwise.
5. Use Social Proof and Word of Mouth
Sometimes, the best way to discover a new coffee is through the recommendations of others. Social media platforms like Instagram or Reddit’s coffee forums often feature passionate coffee drinkers sharing their favorite roasters and brews. If a roaster is consistently praised by those with similar flavor preferences, that’s a strong indicator that their coffee is worth a try.
Pro tip: Look at a roaster’s collaborations with cafes or other brands. If they’re associated with respected names in the specialty coffee world, that’s usually a good sign of quality.
6. Don't Fear the Occasional Risk
Exploration is part of the joy of coffee. While the steps above minimize the chance of buying a bag you don’t love, taking a leap of faith occasionally can lead to delightful surprises. Also, don’t shy away from trying a darker roast or a coffee outside your usual profile - it might expand your palate in unexpected ways.
As Sergi humorously noted, "Grab a diner coffee or a medium roast with cream and sugar - you won’t melt!" Sometimes, stepping outside the specialty coffee bubble can be refreshing.
Key Takeaways
- Start with trusted producers to find new roasters offering coffee aligned with your preferences.
- Study flavor notes on bags to ensure you’re choosing coffees that match your desired profile.
- Examine the processing method for clues about how the coffee will taste.
- Turn to multi-roaster cafes and subscription services for expertly curated options.
- Seek social proof by leveraging recommendations on social media or Reddit.
- Don’t fear failure or taking risks - it’s part of the discovery experience.
- Stay curious: Specialty coffee is always evolving, and every bag is an opportunity to learn and refine your taste.
Conclusion
Discovering new coffee roasters and coffees is more than just a hunt for flavor; it’s an exploration of craft, culture, and connection. By using the strategies outlined here, you’ll minimize the guesswork and maximize the joy of uncovering new favorites. So go ahead - embrace the adventure, pour yourself a cup, and savor the endless possibilities of the specialty coffee world.
Source: "How to find NEW coffee roasters and coffees that you'll love - Coffee Roaster Warm Up Sessions" - Mirror Coffee Roasters, YouTube, Aug 10, 2025 - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qsIlDM1jA-g
